Corporate management declaration
The following section contains the combined corporate governance declaration by the Executive Board and Supervisory Board for HHLA and the Group in accordance with Section 289f of the German Commercial Code (HGB) and Section 315d in conjunction with Section 289f HGB.
Implementation of the Code, declaration of compliance
Responsible and transparent corporate governance geared towards creating sustainable value added has always been a main foundation of HHLA’s commercial success. HHLA therefore expressly supports the German Corporate Governance Code (hereinafter referred to as “the Code” or “GCGC”) and the objectives that it pursues. The Executive Board and Supervisory Board once again carefully studied the recommendations and suggestions of the Code in the 2020 financial year and submitted their annual declaration of compliance in accordance with Section 161 AktG on 11 December 2020. This confirms that the corporate governance and culture of HHLA and the Group comply with the recommendations and most of the suggestions contained in the Code, with the exceptions outlined below.
The current declaration of compliance – as well as those of previous years – is available on the HHLA website at www.hhla.de/corporategovernance and reads as follows:
The Executive Board and Supervisory Board of Hamburger Hafen und Logistik AG hereby state after due examination that in the period starting 13 December 2019 (issue of the previous declaration of compliance), HHLA complied with the recommendations of the German Corporate Governance Code (“the Code” or “GCGC”) in the version dated 7 February 2017 and – subsequent to its taking effect – the version dated 16 December 2019 with the following exceptions. Furthermore, HHLA shall comply with the Code in the future with the following exceptions:
- Not all the members of the Executive Board and Supervisory Board currently comply with the limits on mandates as defined in recommendations C.4 and C.5 GCGC. When selecting candidates for the Executive Board and Supervisory Board, the Supervisory Board and the Nomination Committee have always taken care to ensure that the individuals concerned have enough time to fulfil their commitments. This generally also means that they comply with the limits on mandates defined in recommendations C.4 and C.5. However, the Supervisory Board believes that the question of whether a member has sufficient time for their commitments must be answered according to the circumstances of the individual case. The number of mandates may be an indication, but should not be the only criterion, particularly since there is added value for HHLA when its Board members hold other external mandates. The Supervisory Board therefore believes it is reasonable if members of the Supervisory Board or Executive Board exceed these limits in individual cases.
- According to Section 4.2.3 (2) sentence 2 GCGC in the version dated 7 February 2017, the long-term assessment base for the variable remuneration of Executive Board members should mainly be forward-looking. According to recommendation G.6 GCGC in the version dated 16 December 2019, the share of long-term variable remuneration should exceed the share of short-term variable remuneration. However, the variable remuneration policy which applies to HHLA’s Executive Board is fundamentally based on the achievement of certain key figures and/or targets for a three-year average comprising the current financial year and the two previous financial years. The Supervisory Board is of the opinion that the variable remuneration of the HHLA Executive Board in its current form is already sufficiently geared towards the company’s long-term performance. Nevertheless, the Supervisory Board has started a review of the remuneration system for the Executive Board – also in view of the revision of the GCGC – in the course of which a decision will also be taken on whether to modify the variable remuneration of the Executive Board in future. This review was still ongoing at the time the declaration of compliance was made.
- Section G of the amended Code contains many new recommendations on structuring Executive Board remuneration. This ensures that the remuneration system also determines the relative proportions of fixed salary on the one hand and the short-term variable and long-term variable remuneration in relation to the total target remuneration on the other, and sets an overall cap on total remuneration (G.1). To determine whether the actual total remuneration of the Executive Board members is standard with regard to other companies, the Supervisory Board is to draw up a peer group of other companies and disclose the individual companies (G.3). Furthermore, for each upcoming financial year, the Supervisory Board is to define the performance criteria for all variable remuneration components for each Executive Board member, which should primarily be based on strategic objectives in addition to operational targets (G.7). The long-term variable remuneration granted to each Executive Board member should largely be invested in company shares or otherwise based on the share price. The Executive Board member should only be able to access the long-term variable remuneration after four years (G.10). It is possible to withhold or claw back the variable remuneration in justified cases (G.11). If the service contract with an Executive Board member comes to an end, outstanding variable remuneration components for the period until the contract ends should be paid according to the originally agreed targets and comparative parameters and on the dates or after the holding periods defined in the contract (G.12). The remuneration system for the Executive Board of HHLA in its current form only partially complies with these recommendations, so the company declares the deviation by way of precaution. Variable remuneration for the HHLA Executive Board is not currently divided into short-term and long-term components. There are no plans for share-based components, holding periods or withholding and clawback rights. Instead, the variable remuneration policy which applies to HHLA’s Executive Board is largely based on the achievement of certain key figures and/or targets for a three-year average comprising the current financial year and the two previous financial years. The Supervisory Board is of the opinion that the variable remuneration of the HHLA Executive Board in its current form is already sufficiently geared towards the company’s long-term performance. If any severance payment is made when a contract comes to a premature end, it is generally paid at the departure date. This enables a clear distinction to be made and avoids later arguments. Disclosure of the composition of the peer group was not previously required and has not yet been implemented. In the course of the current review of the remuneration system, the Supervisory Board will decide which of these recommendations HHLA will follow in future.
Hamburg, 11 December 2020
Hamburger Hafen und Logistik Aktiengesellschaft
The Executive Board
The Supervisory Board”
Information about corporate governance practices
Structure and management of the Group
HHLA acts as the strategic management holding company for the Group. Its operating business is primarily conducted by domestic and foreign subsidiaries and associated firms. Group structure Operating activities are managed and monitored by the Executive Board and its central HHLA departments, such as Purchasing, Finance, Legal and HR. Compliance with the management’s corporate governance requirements is ensured by internal company guidelines as well as provisions in the articles of association and rules of procedure for the subsidiaries and associated firms. Most subsidiaries also have their own supervisory or advisory boards that monitor and advise the executive boards of the respective companies.
Compliance
Compliance with corporate guidelines and the statutory provisions relevant to the company’s activities (hereinafter also referred to as “compliance”) is regarded as an essential part of corporate governance at HHLA. The management team in each corporate unit is therefore responsible for ensuring compliance with the applicable statutory provisions for their field of activity and area of responsibility, and for promoting their observance. Workflows and processes must be structured in line with these regulations. The cornerstone of HHLA’s compliance management system (CMS) is a code of conduct, which formulates overriding principles on topics with special relevance for compliance, such as fair competition, the prevention of corruption, discrimination and conflicts of interest, as well as the handling of sensitive corporate information and information subject to data privacy, see www.hhla.de/compliance. The code of conduct also offers the opportunity for employees and third parties to provide information about misconduct within the company. The code of conduct is supplemented by further Group guidelines on such matters as corruption prevention and fair conduct. A further element of the CMS is the systematic, ongoing analysis of compliance risks and the introduction of corresponding measures – such as staff training and process adjustments to minimise the respective risks. Furthermore, a supplier code of conduct together with the business partner screening system, which is currently being implemented on a Group-wide basis to facilitate a risk-oriented assessment of business partners, help to reduce compliance risks. Overall coordination of the CMS is performed by the Group Compliance Officer, who reports directly to the Executive Board and synchronises their activities with those of the Internal Audit and Risk Management departments, among others. There are also compliance managers or officers at the various corporate units in Germany and abroad. The responsibilities of compliance officers primarily include advising employees on all compliance-related issues and investigating any indications of breaches. The Audit Committee monitored the effectiveness of the CMS in the reporting period by means of regular reports from the Executive Board and the Group Compliance Officer. The system will continue to be optimised on an ongoing basis.
Sustainability
Sustainability has been an integral part of HHLA’s business model since the company was established. Sustainability or www.hhla.de/sustainability
Risk management
The HHLA Group’s risk management system is described in detail in the risk and opportunity report, which forms part of the management report. Risk and opportunity report
Transparency
HHLA believes that informing shareholders and interested members of the public promptly about important issues is an integral part of good corporate governance. HHLA provides information about the economic position of the company, as well as important company developments, particularly by means of its financial reporting (annual report, half-yearly financial report and interim statements), press conferences for analysts and financial press conferences, meetings with analysts and the press, press releases and ad hoc announcements as required, and its Annual General Meetings. As a permanently available and up-to-date communication medium, the website www.hhla.de provides all the relevant information in both German and English. In addition to information about the HHLA Group and the HHLA share, it contains a financial calendar with an overview of the important dates. Furthermore, the Investor Relations department is available for all enquiries from shareholders, investors and analysts.
The Executive Board of HHLA
Function of the Executive Board
In accordance with the stipulations of stock corporation law, HHLA has a dual system of management with an Executive Board as management body and a Supervisory Board as monitoring body. The Executive Board manages the company on its own responsibility. It determines the company’s goals, its fundamental strategic orientation and Group policy and organisation. These tasks include, in particular, steering the Group and managing its financing, implementing the HR strategy, appointing and developing managers while paying due consideration to diversity, and representing the company before the capital markets and the general public. It also bears responsibility for appropriate and effective control systems (risk and opportunity management, the compliance management system and the internal control system including Internal Audit).
The Executive Board performs its duties as a collegial body. The members of the Executive Board work together as colleagues and inform each other on an ongoing basis of important developments in their respective areas of responsibility. Regardless of the overall responsibility to manage the company, the individual members of the Executive Board also bear responsibility for the departments assigned to them by Executive Board resolutions and pursuant to the schedule of responsibilities. Fundamental questions of organisation, business policy and corporate planning, as well as measures of greater significance, are discussed and decided upon by the full Executive Board. The Chairwoman of the Executive Board coordinates the work of the Executive Board. This is outlined in more detail in the Executive Board’s rules of procedure.
The Executive Board works in a spirit of mutual trust with the Supervisory Board in the interests of the company. It provides the Supervisory Board with regular, timely and comprehensive information on all matters that are relevant for the company. These include, in particular, profitability, the current position and course of business, strategy, planning, the current risk position, risk management and compliance for both the Group and the company in each case. Certain measures and transactions that are particularly far-reaching – such as adopting the annual budget, initiating new areas of activity, acquiring or selling companies, and capital expenditure or financing measures above a certain size – require the prior approval of the Supervisory Board. The Chairman of the Supervisory Board must be notified without undue delay of any important events of fundamental significance for the assessment of the position and development or the management of the company or the Group, including between meetings. The Chairman of the Supervisory Board is also regularly in touch with the Executive Board, especially the Chairwoman of the Executive Board, between meetings to discuss key issues and current developments, particularly questions of strategy and corporate development, as well as the company’s risk position, risk management and compliance.
The members of the Executive Board are obligated to act in the company’s interests and are bound by an extensive non-compete clause for the duration of their tenure. No member of the Executive Board is permitted to pursue personal interests when making decisions or to utilise business opportunities open to the company for personal gain. Other duties, especially supervisory board posts at companies outside the Group, require the approval of the Supervisory Board. Transactions of material importance between Group companies and members of the Executive Board and parties and companies related to them also require the approval of the Supervisory Board and must be performed on an arm’s-length basis. Conflicts of interest concerning members of the Executive Board must be immediately disclosed to the Chairman of the Supervisory Board. Other members of the Executive Board must also be informed. There were no such transactions or conflicts of interest in the reporting period.
D&O insurance that meets the requirements of Section 93 (2) sentence 3 AktG has been taken out for the members of the Executive Board.
Composition and diversity
In accordance with Article 8 of the articles of association, HHLA’s Executive Board must consist of at least two members. The Executive Board’s members are appointed by the Supervisory Board. Together with the Executive Board, the Supervisory Board ensures there is a long-term succession plan in place and that diversity considerations are taken into account in the Executive Board’s composition. In the interests of outlining diversity aspects more precisely, the Supervisory Board has approved the following diversity concept for the Executive Board.
HHLA’s current Executive Board
Executive Board member
Angela Titzrath Chairwoman of the Executive Board
- Responsibility
- Corporate development
- Corporate communication
- Sustainability
- Container sales
- Intermodal segment
- Logistics segment
Jens Hansen Chief Operating Officer
- Responsibility
- Container operations1
- Container engineering1
- Information systems
Dr. Roland Lappin Chief Financial Officer
- Responsibility
- Finance and controlling (including organisation)
- Investor relations
- Internal audit
- Real Estate segment
Torben Seebold Chief Human Resources Officer
- Responsibility
- HR management
- Purchasing and materials management
- Occupational safety management
- Legal and insurance (including compliance)
1 Without Real Estate, for the Intermodal and Logistics segments as agreed with the Chairwoman of the Executive Board
Objective of the diversity concept
The Executive Board plays a central role in the ongoing development of HHLA and the Group. Along with the professional skills and experience of the Executive Board members, the Supervisory Board therefore believes that diversity aspects play an important role in the sustainable development of the company. Different personalities, experiences and expertise prevent group thinking and facilitate a more holistic approach, thereby enriching the work of the Executive Board.
Diversity aspects
The Supervisory Board strives to ensure that the Executive Board is composed of members whose personal and professional backgrounds, experience and expertise complement one another so that the Executive Board as a whole can draw on the widest possible range of experience, knowledge and skills.
Proportion of women on the Executive Board
When appointing Executive Board members, the Supervisory Board is guided by the model of equal participation by women and men and actively pursues this objective, e.g. by specifically looking for female candidates to join the Executive Board. However, given that the Executive Board is small and there is usually a limited number of suitable candidates, it is not always possible to ensure that women and men are represented equally. With this in mind, the Supervisory Board has set a target quota of 25 % for women on the HHLA Executive Board. It has specified 30 June 2022 as the deadline for achieving this target.
Qualifications and professional background
Diversity in the Executive Board is also reflected by members with different qualifications and career paths who can draw on a wide range of different experiences (such as industry background). Members with different qualifications, professional backgrounds and experiences are therefore actively welcomed. However, each Executive Board member must have the personal and professional skills and experience necessary to fulfil the responsibilities of an Executive Board member at an international, listed company and protect the HHLA Group’s public image. The members of the Executive Board should also have an in-depth understanding of HHLA’s business activities and are usually required to have several years of managerial experience.
Furthermore, with a view to HHLA’s business model, at least one member should have specialist expertise in each of the following areas:
- strategy and strategic management;
- the logistics business, including the relevant markets and client needs;
- sales;
- operations and technology, including IT and digitalisation;
- the real estate business;
- legal affairs, corporate governance and compliance;
- human resources, especially HR management and staff development, as well as experience of co-determined structures; and
- finance, including financing, accounting, controlling, risk management and internal control processes.
International orientation
As the Group’s activities are international by their very nature, at least some of the members should have considerable international experience.
Age
The age limit for Executive Board members is 67. There is no minimum age. However, Executive Board members are generally expected to have several years of managerial experience when they are appointed, which presupposes a certain amount of professional experience. Within this framework, a varied age structure within the Executive Board is targeted – in the interests of diversity and long-term succession planning – although age is deemed less important than the other criteria.
Progress to date
The Executive Board’s current composition fulfils the targets set out above. The Executive Board is currently composed of four people with different career paths, a wide range of experience and varying expertise, including members with considerable international experience. The target quota of 25 % for female executives has been met. The age limit is not exceeded by any member.
Long-term succession planning for the Executive Board
Together with the Executive Board, the Supervisory Board develops long-term succession planning for the Executive Board. With regard to the Supervisory Board, this duty is chiefly performed by the Personnel Committee. Based on the objectives for the composition and expertise of members set out in the diversity concept, a profile of requirements is compiled for each Executive Board position. The requirement profiles, the responsibilities and the performance of the Executive Board members are regularly reviewed by the Personnel Committee – following consultation with the Executive Board/individual Executive Board members – with regard to the current environment, the course of business, the corporate strategy and the areas of expertise represented on the Executive Board.
A further key component of long-term succession planning is the identification and further development of internal candidates for future management roles. It is the responsibility of the Executive Board to identify potential candidates at an early stage so that they can be systematically developed with increasing levels of responsibility and needs-based training. Ideally, there should always be internal candidates on the shortlist whenever new positions need to be filled.
During specific appointment processes, the Personnel Committee and the Supervisory Board will consider not only the aforementioned diversity objectives but also all circumstances of the individual case. Where necessary, the Supervisory Board will also draw on the support of HR consultants.
The Supervisory Board of HHLA
Function of the Supervisory Board
The Supervisory Board decides on the composition of the Executive Board, oversees the Executive Board’s management of the company, advises it on corporate governance and is involved in fundamental and important decisions. Measures and transactions of fundamental importance require the approval of the Supervisory Board in accordance with the Executive Board’s rules of procedure. Its other main tasks include the examination and adoption of the annual financial statements and the approval of the consolidated financial statements.
The tasks and internal organisation of the Supervisory Board and its committees are based on the law, the articles of association and the rules of procedure of the Supervisory Board, which are available on HHLA’s website at www.hhla.de/corporategovernance and www.hhla.de/supervisory-board. The Code also contains recommendations on the Supervisory Board’s work. The Chairman of the Supervisory Board coordinates the work of the Supervisory Board and represents its interests externally.
The members of the Supervisory Board are obligated to act in the company’s interests. No member of the Supervisory Board is permitted to pursue personal interests when making decisions or to utilise business opportunities open to the company for personal gain. Conflicts of interest must be immediately disclosed to the Chairman of the Supervisory Board. The Supervisory Board provides information on conflicts of interest and their treatment in its report to the Annual General Meeting. If a member of the Supervisory Board has significant conflicts of interest that are not merely temporary, this should result in the termination of their tenure. Consultancy agreements or any other contracts for services or works between a member of the Supervisory Board and the company require the approval of the Supervisory Board. There were no such agreements in the 2020 financial year.
D&O insurance with an excess based on Section 93 (2) sentence 3 AktG has been taken out for the members of the Supervisory Board.
Committees
The Supervisory Board carries out its work both in full council and in committees. The individual committees and their responsibilities are laid down in the Supervisory Board’s rules of procedure. The chairpersons of the committees regularly report on the work of their respective committees at the following Supervisory Board meeting. There are currently six committees: the Finance Committee, Audit Committee, Personnel Committee, Nomination Committee, Arbitration Committee and Real Estate Committee.
Finance Committee
Members: Dr. Sibylle Roggencamp (Chair), Thomas Mendrzik (Vice Chair), Dr. Norbert Kloppenburg, Norbert Paulsen, Sonja Petersen, Prof. Dr. Burkhard Schwenker
Responsibilities: The Finance Committee prepares Supervisory Board meetings and resolutions of major financial importance, such as equity acquisitions/disposals, resolutions to be adopted concerning significant borrowing and lending, the assumption of guarantees for third-party liabilities, financial investments and other financial transactions. It also deals with the quarterly reports on the course of business and with planning and investment issues, such as the budget and medium-term planning.
Audit Committee
Members: Dr. Norbert Kloppenburg (Chair), Norbert Paulsen (Vice Chair), Thomas Mendrzik, Dr. Isabella Niklas, Sonja Petersen, Prof. Dr. Burkhard Schwenker
Responsibilities: The Audit Committee is mainly concerned with auditing accounts and monitoring the accounting process, the effectiveness of the internal control system, the risk management system, the internal audit system and compliance. It monitors the auditing of the annual financial statements and its effectiveness, which includes checking the independence of the auditor and any non-audit services, and regularly evaluates the quality of the audit. It is also responsible for preparing the process of electing the auditor (including any shortlisting procedures) and deciding on external reviews of non-financial statements and reports.
Real Estate Committee
Members: Dr. Isabella Niklas (Chair), Norbert Paulsen (Vice Chair), Thomas Lütje, Thomas Mendrzik, Dr. Sibylle Roggencamp, Prof. Dr. Burkhard Schwenker
Responsibilities: The Real Estate Committee is responsible for all issues, reports and decisions that relate either wholly or overwhelmingly to the Real Estate subgroup (S division). In particular, this includes decisions on transactions subject to an approval requirement, examining and preparing the Supervisory Board’s decision on the adoption of the annual financial statements, as well as the approval of the consolidated financial statements, and the proposal on the appropriation of profit insofar as these relate to the Real Estate subgroup.
Personnel Committee
Members: Prof. Dr. Rüdiger Grube (Chair), Berthold Bose (Vice Chair), Thomas Mendrzik, Norbert Paulsen, Dr. Sibylle Roggencamp, Andreas Rieckhof
Responsibilities: The Personnel Committee prepares the personnel decisions to be taken by the Supervisory Board and, together with the Executive Board, ensures that a long-term succession plan is in place. It prepares the Supervisory Board resolution on the remuneration system for Executive Board members and the specification of remuneration for individual members, represents the company, where legally permissible, in other legal transactions with Executive Board members and decides on approving the appointment of authorised signatories.
Nomination Committee
Members: Prof. Dr. Rüdiger Grube (Chair), Andreas Rieckhof, Dr. Sibylle Roggencamp
Responsibilities: In line with the statutory requirements, the rules of procedure, the recommendations of the Code, the skills and requirements matrix for the Supervisory Board and the targets adopted regarding its composition, the Nomination Committee proposes suitable candidates to the Supervisory Board to stand for election at the Annual General Meeting as shareholder representatives on the Supervisory Board.
Arbitration Committee
Members: Prof. Dr. Rüdiger Grube, Berthold Bose, Norbert Paulsen, Andreas Rieckhof
Responsibilities: The Arbitration Committee performs the duties defined in Section 31 (3) of the German Co-Determination Act (MitbestG). This entails making proposals to the Supervisory Board for appointing members of the Executive Board if the statutory majority of two-thirds of the Supervisory Board members’ votes is not reached after the first round of voting.
Composition of the Supervisory Board and diversity
In accordance with the company’s articles of association, Sections 95 and 96 AktG and Section 7 MitbestG, the Supervisory Board consists of six shareholder representatives elected by the Annual General Meeting and six employee representatives elected in accordance with the German Co-Determination Act.
In view of the various requirements and recommendations relating to supervisory board composition, the Supervisory Board of HHLA updated its requirement profile for the Supervisory Board in December 2020 as outlined below. In addition to key legal requirements and the recommendations of the Code concerning supervisory board composition, the requirement profile includes the Supervisory Board’s own objectives for its composition, the skills matrix for the Board as a whole in line with the Code, and the diversity concept for the Supervisory Board, including the disclosures pursuant to Section 289f (1) no. 6 HGB.
Objective of the requirement profile
The Supervisory Board strives for a composition which ensures it is capable of monitoring and advising the Executive Board professionally at all times. The Supervisory Board believes that, in addition to professional and personal requirements, diversity aspects also play an important role for the effective work of the Supervisory Board, and thus for the sustainable development of the company. Different personalities, experiences and expertise prevent group thinking and facilitate a more holistic approach, thereby enriching the Supervisory Board’s work. The objectives below therefore serve as guidelines for long-term succession planning and the selection of suitable candidates. They also provide transparency with regard to the key appointment criteria.
Requirements for individual members
General requirements
Each Supervisory Board member should have the personal and professional skills and experience necessary to fulfil the responsibilities of a Supervisory Board member at an international, listed company and protect the HHLA Group’s public image. In view of this, each Supervisory Board member should fulfil the following requirements:
- sufficient professional knowledge, i.e. the ability to perform the duties which are normally handled by the Supervisory Board;
- commitment, integrity and personality;
- a general understanding of HHLA’s business activities, including the market environment and clients’ needs;
- corporate or operational experience – for shareholder representatives, this should ideally take the form of experience from working in company management teams, occupying a managerial position or sitting on supervisory bodies.
Available time
Each Supervisory Board member ensures that they have enough time to fulfil their Supervisory Board commitments. In particular, it must be taken into account that there are usually four to six Supervisory Board meetings per annum, which each need adequate preparation. Membership of one or more of the committees requires additional time for preparation and attendance of committee meetings. Lastly, additional extraordinary meetings of the Supervisory Board or the committees may become necessary to deal with special topics.
Limits on mandates
Members of the HHLA Supervisory Board who sit on the executive board of a listed company should, as a rule, not serve on the supervisory boards of more than two listed non-Group companies or hold comparable positions and should not serve as the chairperson of the supervisory board of a listed non-Group company. Members of the HHLA Supervisory Board who do not sit on the executive board of a listed company should, as a rule, not hold more than five such external mandates, whereby the role of supervisory board chairman counts twice in this regard. In particular, comparable positions are mandates in the supervisory bodies of foreign listed companies or mandates in the supervisory bodies of companies that are subject to statutory co-determination. On the other hand, membership of the supervisory or advisory boards of smaller companies usually requires a much smaller (time) commitment, meaning that mandates of this kind are generally not regarded as comparable positions.
Age limit and duration of membership
Candidates proposed for election to the Supervisory Board should be under the age of 70 at the time of election. As a rule, members should not serve more than three full terms on the Supervisory Board.
Requirements and objectives for the Supervisory Board as a whole
With regard to the composition of the Supervisory Board as a whole, the Supervisory Board strives to ensure that it is composed of members whose personal and professional backgrounds, experience and expertise complement one another so that the Supervisory Board as a whole can draw on the widest possible range of experience and specialist knowledge. This also serves to promote diversity.
General requirements
The Supervisory Board of HHLA must always be composed in such a way that its members have the necessary knowledge, skills and industry expertise to fulfil the Supervisory Board’s responsibilities properly. Furthermore, the members of the Supervisory Board as a whole must be familiar with the transport and logistics industries – especially the port logistics and intermodal sectors – and the real estate industry, and at least one member of the Supervisory Board must have expertise in the fields of accounting or the auditing of financial statements.
Specific knowledge and experience
The Supervisory Board of HHLA as a whole should cover all the areas of expertise necessary to perform its duties effectively. In line with the company’s business model, this specifically includes in-depth knowledge and experience in:
- managing a large or medium-sized listed company which operates internationally;
- the transport and logistics business, ideally in the port logistics and intermodal sectors, including the relevant markets and clients’ needs;
- operations and technology, including IT systems, information technology and digitalisation;
- the real estate business, specifically letting office space in the Hamburg area;
- legal affairs, corporate governance and compliance;
- controlling and risk management; and
- the auditing of financial statements and the application of accounting principles and internal control processes.
The Supervisory Board strives for a composition whereby at least one member is qualified to provide advice on each of the aspects listed above.
Independence and conflicts of interest
Given HHLA’s specific commercial situation and ownership structure, the Supervisory Board regards it as appropriate that more than half of the shareholder representatives – including the Chairman of the Supervisory Board, the Chairman of the Audit Committee and the Chairman of the Personnel Committee – are independent of the company and of the Executive Board. Furthermore, the Supervisory Board should include at least two members from the Group of shareholder representatives – including the Chairman of the Audit Committee – who are also independent from the controlling shareholder (cf. Recommendations C.6 to C.10 GCGC).
To prevent potential conflicts of interest, no more than two former Executive Board members should sit on the Supervisory Board. Moreover, the Supervisory Board should not include anyone who holds a seat on an executive body or performs an advisory role at any organisation in direct competition with the company or who has personal relations with a direct competitor. If a member of the Supervisory Board has significant conflicts of interest that are not merely temporary, this should result in the termination of their mandate.
Diversity
HHLA’s Supervisory Board consists of at least 30 % women and 30 % men. Furthermore, the Supervisory Board has set itself the medium-term goal of ensuring that 50 % of its shareholder representatives are women.
In addition to this, diversity in the Supervisory Board is reflected by shareholder representatives with different career paths and fields of activity who can draw on a wide range of different experiences (such as training or industry background). In the interests of diversity, the Supervisory Board strives for a composition whereby its members complement one another with their backgrounds, experience and expertise. It also strives to ensure that some of its members have international experience.
Progress to date and future applicability
The Supervisory Board’s current composition fulfils the targets set out above. The Supervisory Board is composed of people with different career paths, a wide range of experience and varying expertise, including members with considerable international experience. The target quota of 30 % for female Supervisory Board members has been met. The age limit was not exceeded by any member at the time of their election. No member has served for more than ten years on the Supervisory Board. Most members comply with the limits on mandates. The majority of shareholder representatives are independent of the company and the Executive Board. Furthermore, the Chairman of the Supervisory Board, Prof. Dr. Grube, the Chairman of the Audit Committee, Dr. Kloppenburg, and Prof. Dr. Schwenker are also independent of the controlling shareholder. Dr. Kloppenburg has expert knowledge and experience in the fields of accounting, auditing and internal control processes, too, thereby fulfilling the requirements in Sections 100 (5) and 107 (4) AktG and Recommendation D.4 GCGC.
The Nomination Committee and the Supervisory Board will take the above requirements and objectives into account during their succession planning and when searching for suitable candidates and proposing them to the Annual General Meeting for election to the Supervisory Board. At the same time, they will strive to fulfil the skills matrix for the Supervisory Board as a whole. However, the Annual General Meeting is under no obligation to observe the requirement profile or the Supervisory Board’s election proposals during the election. The employee representatives are elected by the workforce, who are also not bound by the requirement profile. As such, the Supervisory Board has no right to nominate candidates for such positions.
Self-assessment
The most recent self-assessment with external assistance was carried out in summer 2018 with the aid of an independent consultant. Overall, cooperation was rated very good and efficient. Moreover, the Supervisory Board works continuously to further improve the efficiency of its activities.
Further information
Further information on the composition of the Supervisory Board, the activities of the Supervisory Board and its committees, as well as on the Supervisory Board’s cooperation with the Executive Board in the reporting period, can be found in the Report of the Supervisory Board. The rules of procedure for the Supervisory Board and curricula vitae for the serving members of the Supervisory Board, which also contain information on the career path and other mandates/significant activities of the Supervisory Board member concerned and which are updated annually, are published on the company’s website at www.hhla.de.
Additional information in accordance with Section 289f (2) nos. 4 and 5 HGB
In accordance with Section 96 (2) AktG, the Supervisory Board of HHLA consists of at least 30 % women and 30 % men. There are currently four female members of the Supervisory Board, two of whom are shareholder representatives and two of whom are employee representatives. Women therefore now account for 33.3 % of both the shareholder representatives and the employee representatives on the Supervisory Board. As such, the legal requirements are met.
The Supervisory Board set a quota of 25 % for women on the Executive Board by 30 June 2022. This target has been met.
The Executive Board has set a target quota of 30 % for women in both management levels below the Executive Board and established a deadline for achieving this by 30 June 2022. As of 31 December 2020, women accounted for 25 % of both management levels.
Shareholders and the Annual General Meeting
Shareholders exercise their rights, in particular their voting rights, at the Annual General Meeting. The Annual General Meeting is held within the first eight months of each financial year. Each share entitles its holder to one vote at the Annual General Meeting. There are no shares with multiple voting rights, no preference shares and no caps on voting rights.
Shareholders may exercise their voting rights at the Annual General Meeting in person, by appointing a representative of their choice or by giving voting instructions to proxies designated by the company. The articles of association also authorise the Executive Board to allow shareholders to attend the Annual General Meeting and to exercise individual or all shareholder rights, even if not present at the venue of the Annual General Meeting and without naming a proxy, by means of electronic communication (online participation) and/or to cast their vote in writing or by means of electronic communication (postal vote). The invitation to the Annual General Meeting includes explanations of the participation conditions, the voting procedure (including proxy voting) and the rights of shareholders. In addition, the company has set up a hotline for shareholders’ questions.
The reports and documents required by law for the Annual General Meeting, including the Annual Report, are published on the company’s website at www.hhla.de/annual-general-meeting together with the agenda. Information on attendance at the Annual General Meeting and the voting results can likewise be found on the company’s website after the Annual General Meeting.
Accounting and auditing
The separate financial statements of HHLA (parent company) are prepared in line with the accounting regulations of the German Commercial Code (HGB). The consolidated financial statements and the Interim Reports comply with the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) that apply in the European Union and the additional requirements of German commercial law pursuant to Section 315e (1) HGB. This Annual Report provides further information on IFRS in the notes to the consolidated financial statements, “General notes”. The appropriation of profits is based solely on the separate financial statements. The audit conducted includes an extended audit as stipulated under Section 53 of the German Budgetary Principles Act (HGrG). This requires an audit and assessment of the propriety of the company’s management and its financial situation as part of the audit of the annual financial statements.
The choice and appointment of the auditing firm, the monitoring of its independence and the additional services it provides are all conducted in accordance with statutory provisions. In addition, arrangements have been made with the auditor of the separate financial statements and consolidated financial statements for the 2020 financial year – PricewaterhouseCoopers GmbH Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft, Hamburg – for the chairman of the Audit Committee to be informed immediately of any possible grounds for exclusion or bias arising during the audit, insofar as these are not rectified without delay. The auditor should also report immediately on any findings or incidents that are of significance for the Supervisory Board’s remit which come to his or her attention during the audit of the financial statements. Furthermore, the auditor is to inform the Supervisory Board and/or record in his or her report if – when conducting the audit – he or she identifies facts that indicate that the declaration of compliance as per Section 161 AktG is incorrect.
Further disclosures on members of governing bodies and their mandates
The Executive Board members and their mandates
Angela Titzrath
Chairwoman of the Executive Board
Economist (MA), Hamburg
First appointed: 2016
Current appointment: until 30.09.2024
Other mandates1
- Bionic Production GmbH, Lüneburg2 (Chair) (since 29.08.2019)
- CTD Container-Transport-Dienst GmbH2 (Chair)
- Deutsche Lufthansa AG, Cologne3 (since 02.09.2020)
- Evonik Industries AG, Essen3
- HHLA Digital neXt GmbH2 (since 01.02.2021) (Chair)
- HHLA Frucht- und Kühl-Zentrum GmbH2 (Chair)
- HHLA International GmbH2 (Chair)
- HHLA Sky GmbH2 (Chair)
- HPC Hamburg Port Consulting GmbH2 (Chair)
- METRANS, a.s. (Chair), Prague2
- modility GmbH2 (since 12.10.2020) (Chair)
- Talanx AG, Hanover3
- Ulrich Stein GmbH2 (Chair)
- UNIKAI Lagerei- und Speditionsgesellschaft mbH2 (Chair)
Jens Hansen
Chief Operating Officer
Fully qualified engineer, fully qualified business administration manager, Elmshorn
First appointed: 2017
Current appointment: until 31.03.2025
Other mandates1
- Cuxcargo Hafenbetrieb GmbH & Co. KG, Cuxhaven4 (Chair)
- Cuxcargo Hafenbetrieb Verwaltungs-GmbH, Cuxhaven4 (Chair)
- DAKOSY Datenkommunikationssystem AG4 (Chair)
- HCCR Hamburger Container- und Chassis-Reparatur-Gesellschaft mbH2 (Chair)
- HHLA Container Terminal Altenwerder GmbH2 (Chair)
- HHLA Container Terminal Burchardkai GmbH2 (Chair)
- HHLA Container Terminal Tollerort GmbH2 (Chair)
- HHLA Rosshafen Terminal GmbH2
- HHLA TK Estonia AS, Tallinn2 (Chair)
- HPC Hamburg Port Consulting GmbH2
- HVCC Hamburg Vessel Coordination Center GmbH2
- Hyperport Cargo Solutions GmbH i. Gr.4
- iSAM AG, Mühlheim an der Ruhr (since 19.01.2021) (Chair)
- SCA Service Center Altenwerder GmbH2 (Chair)
- Service Center Burchardkai GmbH2 (Chair)
Dr. Roland Lappin
Chief Financial Officer
Fully qualified industrial engineer, Hamburg
First appointed: 2003
Current appointment: until 30.04.2026
Other mandates1
- Fischmarkt Hamburg-Altona GmbH2 (Chair)
- GHL Zweite Gesellschaft für Hafen- und Lagereiimmobilien-Verwaltung mbH2 (Chair)
- Hansaport Hafenbetriebsgesellschaft mbH4
- HHLA Frucht- und Kühl-Zentrum GmbH2
- HHLA Immobilien Speicherstadt GmbH2
- HHLA International GmbH2
- HHLA Rosshafen Terminal GmbH2
- IPN Inland Port Network GmbH & Co. KG4
- IPN Inland Port Network Verwaltungsgesellschaft mbH4
- METRANS, a.s, Prague2
- Spherie UG (haftungsbeschränkt)4 (until 31.08.2020)
- Ulrich Stein GmbH2
- UNIKAI Lagerei- und Speditionsgesellschaft mbH2
Torben Seebold
Chief Human Resources Officer
Fully qualified lawyer, Hamburg
First appointed: 2019
Current appointment: until 31.03.2022
Other mandates1
- Gesamthafenbetriebs-Gesellschaft mbH, Hamburg (Chair)
- HHLA-Personal-Service GmbH2 (Chair)
- Verwaltungsausschuss für den Hafenfonds der Gesamthafenbetriebs-Gesellschaft, Hamburg
The Supervisory Board members and their mandates
Prof. Dr. Rüdiger Grube (Chairman)
Fully qualified engineer, Hamburg
Managing Partner of Rüdiger Grube International Business Leadership GmbH
Supervisory Board member since: June 2017
Other mandates1
- Bombardier Transportation (Bahntechnologie) Holding Germany GmbH, Berlin (Chair) (since 11.05.2019)
- Bombardier Transportation GmbH, Berlin (Chair) (since 11.05.2019)
- Deufol SE, Hofheim am Taunus
- Herrenknecht AG, Schwanau
- RIB Software SE, Stuttgart3
- Vantage Towers AG, Düsseldorf (Chair) (since 01.10.2020)
- Vossloh AG, Werdohl3 (Chair) (since 05.02.2020)
Berthold Bose (Vice Chairman)
Automotive electrician, Hamburg
Head of ver.di Hamburg
Supervisory Board member since: June 2017
Other mandates1
- Asklepios Kliniken Hamburg GmbH, Hamburg
- HGV Hamburger Gesellschaft für Vermögens- und Beteiligungsmanagement mbH5
Dr. Norbert Kloppenburg
Fully qualified agricultural engineer, Hamburg
International investments and financing consultant
Supervisory Board member since: June 2012
Other mandates1
- Voith GmbH & Co. KGaA, Heidenheim
Thomas Lütje
Shipping agent, Jork
Director of Sales at Hamburger Hafen und Logistik AG
Supervisory Board member since: June 2017
Other mandates1
- HVCC Hamburg Vessel Coordination Center GmbH2 (Chair)
Thomas Mendrzik
Electrical technician, Hamburg
Technical employee at HHLA Container Terminal Altenwerder GmbH
Supervisory Board member since: June 2017
Other mandates1
- HGV Hamburger Gesellschaft für Vermögens- und Beteiligungsmanagement mbH5 (until 19.09.2019)
- HHLA Container Terminal Altenwerder GmbH (until 18.04.2019)
- SCA Service Center Altenwerder GmbH (until 18.04.2019)
Dr. Isabella Niklas
Doctorate in law, Hamburg
Management spokeswoman for HGV Hamburger Gesellschaft für Vermögens- und Beteiligungsmanagement mbH
Supervisory Board member since: June 2018
Other mandates1
- GMH Gebäudemanagement Hamburg GmbH5
- HADAG Seetouristik und Fährdienst AG5
- Hanseatische Wertpapierbörse Hamburg (since 07.02.2020)
- Hapag-Lloyd AG3, 6 (since 05.06.2020)
- SBH Schulbau Hamburg5
- SNH Stromnetz Hamburg GmbH5
- Wärme Hamburg GmbH (formerly Vattenfall Wärme GmbH)5
Norbert Paulsen
Fully qualified engineer, Hamburg
Chairman of the Group works council and joint works council of Hamburger Hafen und Logistik AG
Supervisory Board member since: June 2012
Other mandates1
- HGV Hamburger Gesellschaft für Vermögens- und Beteiligungsmanagement mbH5
Sonja Petersen
Fully qualified business administration manager (FH), Norderstedt
Clerical employee at HHLA Container Terminal Burchardkai GmbH
Supervisory Board member since: June 2017
Other mandates1
- None
Andreas Rieckhof
MA in history, political science, and social and economic history, Hamburg
State Secretary at the Hamburg Ministry for the Economy, Transport and Innovation (Economy and Innovation department)
Supervisory Board member since: August 2020
Other mandates1
- FHG Flughafen Hamburg GmbH Group5
- Hamburger Hochbahn AG (until 27.08.2020)
- Hamburger Verkehrsverbund GmbH (Chair) (until 14.07.2020)
- Hamburgische Investitions- und Förderbank AöR (from 15.07.2020 until 08.09.2020)
- Hamburg Verkehrsanlagen GmbH (Chair) (until 14.07.2020)
- HHT Hamburg Tourismus GmbH5 (Chair) (since 15.07.2020)
- HIW Hamburg Invest Wirtschaftsförderungsgesellschaft mbH5 (Chair) (since 15.07.2020)
- HMC Hamburg Messe und Congress GmbH5 (Chair) (since 15.07.2020)
- Life Science Nord Management GmbH5 (Chair in even years) (since 15.07.2020)
- ReGe Hamburg Projekt-Realisierungsgesellschaft mbH5 (Chair)
- Verkehrsbetriebe Hamburg-Holstein AG (Chair) (until 14.07.2020)
- ZAL Zentrum für Angewandte Luftfahrtforschung GmbH5 (Chair) (since 15.07.2020)
Dr. Sibylle Roggencamp
Fully qualified economist, Molfsee
Head of the Office for Asset and Investment Management at the Hamburg Ministry of Finance
Supervisory Board member since: June 2012
Other mandates1
- Elbphilharmonie und Laeiszhalle Service GmbH5
- Flughafen Hamburg GmbH5
- Hamburg Musik GmbH5
- Hamburger Hochbahn AG5
- Hamburgischer Versorgungsfonds AöR5
- HSH Beteiligungsmanagement GmbH5 (until 23.01.2019)
- HSH Portfoliomanagement AöR, Kiel5 (Chair)
- Sprinkenhof GmbH5 (Chair) (until 14.07.2020)
- Universitätsklinikum Hamburg-Eppendorf (UKE) KöR, Hamburg5
Prof. Dr. Burkhard Schwenker
Fully qualified business administration manager, Hamburg
Chairman of the Advisory Council of Roland Berger GmbH
Supervisory Board member since: June 2019
Other mandates1
- Flughafen Hamburg GmbH5
- Hamburger Sparkasse AG (HASPA), Hamburg
- Hensoldt Holding GmbH, Taufkirchen
- M.M. Warburg & Co. KGaA, Hamburg (since 01.01.2020)
Maya Schwiegershausen-Güth
MA in political science, sociology, and economic and social history, Berlin
Head of the Maritime Economy group, ver.di Bund
Supervisory Board member since: June 2017
Other mandates1
- Hapag-Lloyd AG, Hamburg3, 6
Members who departed in 2020
Dr. Torsten Sevecke
Doctorate in law, Hamburg
State Secretary at the Hamburg Ministry for the Economy, Transport and Innovation (Economy and Innovation department) (until June 2020)
Supervisory Board member since: June 2018
Other mandates1
- 4Free AG, Hamburg
- Erneuerbare Energien Hamburg Clusteragentur GmbH5 (Chair) (until 14.07.2020)
- Hamburg Messe und Congress GmbH5 (Chair) (until 14.07.2020)
- Hamburg Tourismus GmbH5 (Chair) (until 14.07.2020)
- Hamburgische Investitions- und Förderbank AöR5 (until 14.07.2020)
- HGV Hamburger Gesellschaft für Vermögens- und Beteiligungsmanagement mbH5 (until 14.07.2020)
- HIW Hamburg Invest Wirtschaftsförderungsgesellschaft mbH5 (Chair) (until 14.07.2020)
- Life Science Nord Management GmbH5 (Chair) (until 14.07.2020)
- ReGe Hamburg Projekt-Realisierungsgesellschaft mbH5 (until 14.07.2020)
- ZAL Zentrum für Angewandte Luftfahrtforschung GmbH5 (Chair) (until 14.07.2020)
1 Seats on statutory supervisory boards and comparable supervisory bodies at domestic and foreign companies
2 HHLA holds a majority interest (directly or indirectly). Registered office in Hamburg unless otherwise stated
3 Listed
4 HHLA holds a minority or equal interest (directly or indirectly). Registered office in Hamburg unless otherwise stated
5 Company associated with the Free and Hanseatic City of Hamburg (excluding HHLA Group companies). Registered office in Hamburg unless otherwise stated
6 The Free and Hanseatic City of Hamburg (excluding HHLA Group companies) holds a minority interest. Registered office in Hamburg unless otherwise stated
Production value – intermediate inputs (cost of materials, depreciation and amortisation, and other operating expenses); the value added generated is shared between the HHLA Group’s stakeholders, such as employees, shareholders, lenders and the local community.
Transportation via several modes of transport (water, rail, road) combining the specific advantages of the respective carriers.
Payments for investments in property, plant and equipment, investment property and intangible assets.
International financial reporting standards.
In maritime logistics, a terminal is a facility where freight transported by various modes of transport is handled.
In maritime logistics, a terminal is a facility where freight transported by various modes of transport is handled.
Payments for investments in property, plant and equipment, investment property and intangible assets.